Charlie Craig and David Mullins filed a complaint under Colorado's anti-discrimination laws after Phillips told them in 2012 he wouldn't make them a wedding cake due to his religious objections to gay marriage. They'd planned to marry in MA, since same-sex marriage wasn't legal nationwide at the time, and hold a reception in Colorado.
Phillips says that he has the right, under the First Amendment's Free Exercise clause, to refuse a customer who would force him to violate his religious beliefs.
The case will be a major test of a clash between laws that ban businesses open to the public from discriminating based on sexual orientation and claims of religious freedom.
The opinions expressed in this article are exclusively those of the author and are not necessarily those of World Religion News.
The Court will hear the case in its next term beginning in October.
But while LGBTQ rights groups like Lambda cheered the court's decision in Arkansas, they were disappointed that justices chose to review the decision in Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission.
"The constitution guarantees me the right to practice my faith, my religion, anywhere, any time", Phillips said in 2015.
The justices issued an unsigned opinion reversing an Arkansas high court ruling that upheld the law. When a baker makes a wedding cake, is he or she declaring support for the couple's marriage?
In the cake case, Charlie Craig and David Mullins approached Masterpiece Cakeshop to order a cake for their wedding reception. That solution would've been eminently sensible since the court has never held that commercial businesses have a constitutional right to discriminate against a certain class of customers.
The suburban Denver baker argues that he did not turn away the gay couple in 2012 because they were gay, but because their marriage violated his religious belief. Washington's state supreme court ruled unanimously in February that a florist violated state law by refusing to sell flowers to a gay couple for their wedding.
After losing the long-running court case previous year, bakers Melissa and Aaron Klein were ordered to pay $135,000 in costs and damages.
The brief also said Craig and Mullins could purchase a wedding cake from another bakery.
- The Boston Celtics Take Jayson Tatum
- Green leading vote-getter for All-Defensive team
- The song that begat 'Baby Driver,' a quasi-musical on wheels
- Federer struggles for 11th Gerry Weber final
- Corruption charge increases pressure on Brazil's president
- This Feels Like A Dream Run: Kidambi Srikanth
- Chinese Foreign Minister welcomed by Punjab CM at Islamabad airport
- Di Maria agrees deal in Spain over tax fraud
- 79 now believed to have died in London high-rise fire
- Another leadership test for Pelosi, who's weathered many